Mandela, Education, and What Didn’t Come to Be

12.08.13

Mandela, Education, and What Didn’t Come to Be

12.08.13
Dylan ThomasDylan Thomas

In the wake of Nelson Mandela’s death this past Thursday, media channels have been jamming up with quotes from the influential South African political leader. But they’re not exactly what you would expect. Though somewhat varied in theme, Mandela’s most reproduced quotes center on the topic of education – a departure from what one would anticipate of the man who is almost exclusively credited with ending apartheid in South Africa. So why is the former political revolutionary being remembered across media channels in connection with his efforts to improve education? When Mandela announced his candidacy for presidency in the early 1990s, he ran on a Reconstruction and Development Programme platform that was dedicated to three main goals: to build one million houses in five years, extend the country’s access to water and electricity, and introduce universal free education.

The statistics for improvement in education in South Africa since the Mandela government was implemented are impressive. By 1999, 1.5 million children were brought into the education system and over 1,000 new schools were built and 4,500 renovated. The matriculation pass rate of students has almost doubled in poorer provinces across the country and ten years after Mandela’s election, literacy rates in the country increased by 6 percent. By 2005, the South African government was spending an astonishing 20 percent of its budget on education.

Unfortunately, these statistics are also misleading. It seems quality has been neglected for quantity in the proposed improvement of the South African educational system. The numbers are impressive from a growth standpoint, yet the quality of South Africa’s education leaves a lot to be desired. The World Economic Forum’s competitiveness index for 2012 - 2013 ranked South Africa’s overall education system at 140 out of 144 countries.

The main problem cited for the failure of the South African educational system is under-qualified teachers. David Silman, a director at the basic education department acknowledges, “The content knowledge of teachers is a serious challenge.” In many cases teachers will skip areas of the curriculum they feel uncomfortable teaching or ignore curriculum guidelines altogether. Other obstacles include a severe lack of school management, which was exacerbated when the Mandela government parsed power over the schools away from the government center and towards the individual provinces. The result has led to poor policy implementation, inferior training of teachers and bureaucrats, and a system many people have lost faith in.

There is no doubt that the South African educational system leaves a lot to be desired in its current state, across subject areas. Though Mandela spent some time in philanthropic efforts to address the issue of the AIDs pandemic in the country after his term as president, his efforts during his time in office through educational avenues left a lot of issues unanswered.

Mandela’s effort in 1995 to develop the National Policy on HIV and AIDs Education set forth the guidelines for teaching sexual education and education on HIV/AIDs in secondary schools but never set a compulsory curriculum or specific programs. Today, statistics for treatment is on the rise and those for infection among children are declining, but South Africa maintains one of the highest population percentages with the virus in the world – disappointing news for the country, considering the US announcement in March of 2013 of its plan to cut the budget for South African aid by 50 percent by 2017 due to the economic crisis and budget cuts.

There is no doubt that Nelson Mandela himself was a great testament to education. Even through his imprisonment, he continued to study remotely and earn various degrees despite the extreme censorship that prison security executed over his study materials. His efforts to make education more accessible and the results he saw from these efforts cleared the way for serious social improvement. Unfortunately, it seems that the growth Mandela made room for with his reforms never amounted to the quality instruction South African students need.

3 comments
3 comments
wondermint
wondermint

I couldn't agree more.   Spot on analysis of Mandela's legacy in South Africa.  Look forward to more posts by the author.

eprileson
eprileson

Great analysis on the issue of education; certainly something that tends to be glossed over when discussing South Africa.


You might have been able to extend your discussion on educational achievement to include disparities based on race since Mr. Mandela is chiefly known for ending South Africa's segregation system. Many whites have moved out of the public education system reversing some of the gains of integration. http://www.stanford.edu/~jbaugh/saw/Lizet_Education_Inequity.html


Like education in our country, the struggles in administration of school standards and teacher training are part of the larger question of whether education is better served being  managed at the national level or at the local level. In the case of South Africa, a more active federal presence (beyond cash) may be necessary to solve these issues. 


Thanks for your terrific piece and for reminding readers to look beyond the rosy glow of posthumous memories.

owilson
owilson


@eprileson 

Thanks for the link - the rift in quality and demographic between public and private education in S Africa is definitely an indicator of how much work there is left to be done - in both the education and integration spheres.


  • Raqqa Media Center
    Raqqa Media Center

    Erasing the Past: ISIS, Palmyra and Doomed History

  • Jonathan Snyder/USAF
    Jonathan Snyder/USAF

    U.S. Bombers to Australia: Washington’s Deployments in the Pacific

  • Reuters
    Reuters

    Curious Turnaround: The British Election 2015

  • New York Times
    New York Times

    Lies, Lies, and The Death of Bin Laden

  • Reuters
    Reuters

    Yemen Re-Draws Middle East Alliances

  • Associated Press
    Associated Press

    Violence in Kumanovo: Macedonia and the Virtues of Corruption

  • Reuters
    Reuters

    The Case for Castro: Why the Embargo Needs to End in 2015

    05.08.15
  • Alexis Tsipras/Facebook
    Alexis Tsipras/Facebook

    Greece’s Tussle with Turkey, Key to Athens’ Economic Comeback?

    05.07.15
  • Nicola Sturgeon/Facebook
    Nicola Sturgeon/Facebook

    The Sturgeon Factor: The Scottish National Party and the British Elections